Negril vs. Montego Bay: Your Next Jamaica Beach Vacation

Jamaica’s Caribbean shores are calling your name and your tropical escape awaits. However, when it comes to Negril vs. Montego Bay, it can be difficult to decide which is the best option. The question isn’t which one is better, as both destinations are clear winners when it comes to soft sand, warm beaches and island activities. Instead, choose the destination that best fits your style.

Negril’s laidback pace and stunning sunsets make it a restorative haven with a touch of class, best for romance-seeking couples and slower-paced travelers. Montego Bay is a high-energy hotspot with dense attractions and pockets of lively beach access, best for social, active travelers. 

This comprehensive guide breaks down the unique features of each region’s atmosphere, beach scene, activities and accommodations so you can confidently book your dream vacation.

Daniel Grill / Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Negril is on the western tip of Jamaica and it takes about 1.5 to 2 hours to arrive at tourist zones, a longer commute than Montego Bay. But travelers agree it’s worth the journey. Guests are rewarded with cliffside sunsets, miles of walkable sand and a mix of laid-back bars and jerk shacks to enjoy between sightseeing. 

While Negril’s scene may be too tame for partygoers who prefer dense nightlife, it’s perfect for families seeking a slower pace, leisurely solo travelers and couples seeking picturesque romantic accommodations. 

Montego Bay is Caribbean convenience at its best, just minutes from the nearest airport, so vacationers can go from customs to the beach in less than an hour. The Hip Strip is popular for accommodations, dining, entertainment and people-watching, all along the coastline. 

While Montego Bay is action-packed and there’s never a dull moment, it’s also the most popular tourist location, so expect big crowds, including those from nearby cruise ports. The region may be the perfect fit if you enjoy high-energy, social exploration.

Thanasis / Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Negril exudes serenity, with slow-tempoed reggae beats and leisurely pursuits along the whole stretch of the Seven Mile Beach. Visitors trade hustle and bustle for unadulterated sunsets and hammock naps. If you want to spend your time in Jamaica lounging on pillowy sands, walking the modest town center and unwinding on gentle river floats, Negril is the right fit. 

Numbeo assigns Negril a crime index of 66.5 and a safety index of 33.5. While this is a lower crime rate than the capital city, Kingston, it’s higher than the global average. However, perceived daytime safety is moderate, making it safe for attentive families. For the safest bet, stick to the West End and Seven Mile Beach, two well-secured regions in town. 

Montego Bay is brimming with energy, variety and fast-paced activities. If it’s your first time visiting the island, this is the place to go if you want to try a bit of everything. It’s a major cruise port and launchpad for excursions, so you can expect bigger crowds than Negril, especially during high season. The Hip Strip’s seaside path greets you with wafts of smoke from jerk shacks, lively street music and the hum of darting taxis, placing you in the heart of the action. 

Montego Bay’s Numbeo crime index is higher at 71.13, with a lower safety index of 28.87. As the second largest city in Jamaica with busy international air and cruise ports, a broader range of individuals and experiences contribute to higher perceived safety. The Hip Strip and downtown regions are well-monitored during the day. Gated villas, all-inclusives and hotels also offer exceptional on-premise security. 

When it comes to staying safe in Montego Bay vs. Negril, the best bet is to stay at a reputable property with staffed security and explore public areas during the daytime, especially if traveling with small children.

narvikk / Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Seven Mile Beach is the showstopper on Negril’s shore, a palm-lined multi-mile strip of turquoise waters and soft white sand. The iconic Jamaican beaches are wide open and popular for their tranquil views. The beaches are swimmable and accessible for both day visits and from nearby hotels and resorts. You can find even calmer waters in Bloody Bay and experience unforgettable sunsets at West End Cliffs. 

Fewer vendors pace Negril’s beaches, especially at less frequented locales beyond the Seven Mile Beach region. The vibe is laidback and friendly, perfect for relaxed beach days, romantic sunset strolls and long, leisurely swims.

Montego Bay’s beaches are highly social, best for parties, people-watching and amenities. However, the beach scene is condensed into select bays due to the rugged, rock and coral-filled coastline and many piers. Even though Montego Bay’s beaches are smaller, plenty of activity is packed into a tight footprint. 

Doctor’s Cave Beach offers a party atmosphere and serves as the Montego Bay Marine Park entrance, which hosts a protected offshore reef. For a less crowded yet lively option, head to the bay-protected Cornwall Beach. Dead End Beach is a lesser-known gem, best for laid-back lounging with locals.

Roberto Moiola / Sysaworld / Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Negril’s calming atmosphere, open, gentle waters and modestly-sized town center keep logistics simple for families who want a relaxed, slow-paced vacation. The shallow beaches are ideal for small children and toddlers, with little to no undertow. Multigenerational travelers can take advantage of low-pressure excursions like river floats, butterfly gardens or a glass-bottomed boat tour along the Negril River. 

Montego Bay offers tailor-made family experiences that are closer than those in Negril. The Sangster International Airport is just 5 to 15 minutes away from popular resorts and beaches, minimizing long drives for young ones and older travelers. Montego Bay is best for snorkeling with colorful fish and a nearby reef. The beachfront AquaSol Theme Park is a big hit with kids, as well as the peaceful Rocklands Bird Sanctuary.

Witthaya Prasongsin / Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Negril’s quieter stretch has a less developed feel and unspoiled scenery, making it a winner for nature-based excursions. For a rush of adrenaline just 10 minutes outside Negril’s center, visitors can jump off the West End Cliffs or watch other brave folks from the comfort of Rick’s Café. 

Booby Cay Island is a 10-minute boat ride away and offers peaceful snorkeling and birdwatching opportunities. Some of the best things to do in Negril require a couple of hours of driving, such as a visit to the YS falls or Mayfield Falls. 

Montego Bay’s relatively compact layout makes it easy to pair cultural immersion with beach relaxation. Many of the best things to do in Montego Bay are just steps away from the hotel-packed Hip Strip, which means less commuting for visitors who prefer to stay central. 

History buffs can tour the nearby Rose Hall House, while nature lovers can snorkel in the Montego Bay Marine Park. Just 30 minutes north of town, vacationers experience the unique bamboo rafts along the Martha Brae River.

Thanasis / Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Negril’s luxury boutique accommodations line the beach, with a concentration on Seven Mile Beach and Bloody Bay. Guests who plan to spend long hours on the beach can stay at Sandals Negril Beach Resort & Spa for pristine beach access paired with Four Diamond amenities. Beaches Negril Resort & Spa boasts a water park and an abundance of child-friendly programming, perfect for families seeking low-effort entertainment. 

Budget travelers can find smaller guesthouses and inns slightly off the main track. Look for accommodations at the northern tip of Seven Mile’s stretch to stay beachside at a value. The West End district also offers affordable options, often situated on coastal cliffscapes. 

Montego Bay’s towering resorts and hotels are concentrated into two main zones, the Hip Strip and Rose Hall Resort Area. The Hip Strip is a coastal road at the edge of Montego Bay’s downtown, only 5 minutes from Sangster International Airport. It's easy to explore the city on foot while being close to your lodging, which is often walkable.

Stay at S Hotel Jamaica for direct access to Doctor’s Cave Beach and Sandals Montego Bay, which are adults-only, all-inclusive paradises. The Hip Strip and neighboring streets also have budget-friendly, simple hotels with fewer amenities, but still close to the action. 

Rose Hall Resort Area is a master-planned zone about 20 minutes east of the Hip Strip. Visitors can stay at stand-out venues like the Hilton Rose Hall Resort & Spa, featuring a long stretch of private beach and all-ages activities. Within the Rose region, visitors can golf, visit boutique shops and take advantage of sailing and diving opportunities without leaving the zone. 

Bill Stevenson / 500px/ Getty Images / CC BY-SA

Negril's nightlife scene is present yet laidback, with bonfire parties, live music and lively local clubs like Bourbon Beach and Jungle. Expect easygoing sunset soirees and chill bar crawls that give way to low-key DJs in open-air venues. Cover fees are scarce and tropical libations are affordable, but venues are further apart and more challenging to get to on foot. Couples and low-key travelers regularly flock to Negril’s vibrant yet mellow after-hours scene. 

Montego Bay’s nightlife turns up the volume and extends late into the night with bigger, busier clubs and lively bar hopping along the Hip Strip and within the resorts. You can easily walk on foot to popular strip attractions like Blue Beat Ultra Lounge or Margaritaville Montego Bay. Take a water taxi to Pier 1 or Elevate Rooftop for off-strip fun. The Rose Hall Resort zone is best for high-end theater performances, piano bars and slightly less crowded beachfront entertainment. 

Here are quick answers to common questions travelers have about Negril or Montego Bay: 

Both Montego Bay and Negril have many charming offerings. When deciding where to stay in Jamaica, consider the type of trip you’re planning. 

Montego Bay is located on the north side of Jamaica and is a popular destination for a lively resort and nightlife scene. 

Negril’s located on the far western tip of the island. It’s known for unforgettable sunsets, long stretches of beach and scenic cliff views.

Montego Bay and Negril are approximately 50 miles apart. The trip by car takes between 1.5 and 2 hours. If you plan on visiting both, you can arrange a shared shuttle or private transportation. The road is well-paved and passes by scenic stretches of jungle and turquoise waters.

While Negril is less known for its nightlife scene than Montego Bay, there are plenty of party venues. Popular choices include Margaritaville Negril’s lively beach parties, Rick’s Café and the Jungle Nightclub. 

Jamaica’s landmass is just under that of the state of Connecticut and yet it’s so rich with travel possibilities that it can be a challenge to choose between Negril vs. Montego Bay. The right choice boils down to the activities and atmosphere that align with your dream vacation.

For an unhurried, nature-forward vacation, Negril fits the bill, best for restorative travelers, laid-back families and couples. Active families, nightlife-lovers and solo-adventurers may prefer Montego Bay for its easy access to cultural and natural attractions. 

Ready to book your trip? AAA Travel provides peace of mind — before, during and after your vacation. A membership includes exclusive benefits, map routing and hotel and restaurant recommendations. Our team can help you decide the best time to visit Jamaica based on your schedule and budget. Let AAA help you book your island getaway today.